So now that I am 88, I really am finally learning what it means to “grow old”. It’s all about Letting Go and Moving On. It means adapting to new realities. Letting go of dear friends or a life partner is the hardest. After seven years without Jack, even as I miss his hugs terribly, I am ever more aware of his presence.  I am shifting from feeling so responsible for others to taking better care of myself.

In 2019 I joined a local theater board to help them incorporate DEI goals. I am leaving that organization in June because I realize that I am no longer as energetic or competent to lead others as I once was. My memory is slow to recall names. I forget to attend scheduled meetings.  My thinking is slower, even to express an opinion. I am done with that phase of my life—well, not with expressing opinions if asked! But I am adapting to my awareness of diminishing energy and ambition.  I listen more and observe others who are younger taking over. It pleases me.

I made three promises to myself when I retired in 1995 from my beloved teaching and directing at Boulder High School which had consumed both time and energy for 15 years: to give priority to care of my body and my spiritual growth; to read as many books as I wanted; and to develop friendships with women.   

My life at 88 is now, finally, about taking care of me.  Maintenance is the necessary work of our later years. I swim in our condo’s pool for exercise and release. I joined a yoga class and am the oldest in the class. I get congratulations for just showing up. My body feels better too—more flexible joints, less creaky. I eat when I want and fix what I like and share the extra with Beth or friends who’ve given up cooking.

I read many books for enjoyable company and to learn more, especially how history informs our present-day issues.  Here’s my list of some of the top books I have most enjoyed:

Caste: The Origins of Our Discontent  by Isabel Wilkerson; The Sixth Extinction by Elizabeth Kolbert; Inheritance by Dani Shapiro; A Woman of No Importance by Sonia Purnell; The American Lion by Jon Meacham; The Night Watchman by Louise Erdrich; Deacon King Kong by James McBride; Becoming Duchess Goldblatt by Anonymous; The Water Dancer by Ta Nahesi Coates.

My three book groups have led to closer friendships with women I admire and whose company I enjoy. I attend a weekly lunchtime Zoom Bible study. Not only does is feed my spiritual growth by discussing current issues as they relate to biblical teachings, but this small group of mostly women has become a meaningful support circle.  I still love going to the theatre, to concerts, and occasional travel still appeals. It all feeds my mind and soul. I write letters or make spontaneous phone calls or texts to connect with others, and I continue to nurture my spiritual path that readies me for transitioning to another reality when the time comes. I am done with “productions” and “projects” that require a lot of time and effort. My focus now is more about relationships and being with people I care about and for the give and take of both new and enduring friendships. I take more time now for acts of kindness. I have become a modest philanthropist by supporting others who provide compassionate human services or organize for positive social change.

This is what I now know with certainty: Love is the bridge that connects us, even in death.

Watery Wisdom
Beginning a new chapter of life is a lot like jumping off a high diving board without a life preserver. You have to trust the water to hold you up and yourself to know how to paddle to safety. The wonder is that you can do it with practice and, finally, without fear.

From Jean Hodges

Past-President PFLAG National
and PFLAG Boulder County
4475 Laguna Place #207
Boulder, CO 80303
303-444 4580

 

My heart has been heavy during this holiday season since I learned of the death by suicide of Alana Chen.  From my 25+ years of commitment to PFLAG, the oldest national organization that supports our LGBTQ children and their families, I have been committed to changing minds and hearts to affirm our LGBTQ children and seek equality for those whose sexuality and gender identity does not conform to society’s expectations.  

I am proud that our two Boulder County school districts have gradually included policies and professional trainings that protect LGBTQ students and staff so they feel safe to succeed in school without discrimination and rejection just for being who they are.  

I am proud that significant legislative progress began in l996 when Colorado’s Amendment 2, which legalized discrimination in public accommodations for gays and lesbians, was struck down by the US Supreme Court. Most of us were elated when Marriage Equality became our national law in 2015.  Nevertheless, the 2016 election made clear that the national struggle for LGBTQ equality was far from over. Fearful reluctance to adapt to changing times has had tragically inhumane consequences.

However, I am a person of hope.  In 2019, despite regressive national executive orders, a progressive Colorado legislature moved several bills forward with informed understanding of the legal difficulties and emotional trauma for LGBTQ persons who struggled to navigate systems which did not respect their humanity.  One of these bills made conversion therapy illegal.  Yet Alana was entrapped by this perverse practice that asserts religious belief over scientific fact.

I am also a person of faith.  I painfully struggle to understand how the Christian imperative to love one another unconditionally, as taught and practiced by Jesus, can be superseded by ecclesiastical policies and ingrained beliefs that devalue those who are different in race, culture, or their very human identity. As a lifelong Methodist, I am ashamed of the General Conference of the United Methodist Church that resists changing their anti-gay policies. It is tearing this worldwide church apart.  So I am not castigating another faith tradition without recognizing that long-held prejudice and ignorance about sexual orientation and gender identity does damage beyond repair in diverse cultural and religious traditions. I weep in despair that our imbedded fears command actions that end with heart-breaking results.

The dark shadow of Alana Chen’s tragic death continues to hover over our community.  Most poignantly, her family is devastated by the loss of a beloved daughter and sister whom they loved and accepted just as she was. Yet Alana met privately, even secretly without parental consent, with clergy whose influence led not to conversion but to increased depression.  How can the priests not recognize and recant their dangerous counsel? Or at least apologize to the Chen family? Alana was an innocent victim of a hurtful and false belief system.

Being gay, lesbian, bisexual or transgender is not a disease that can be caught.  It is not a mental aberration that can disappear with “right thinking”.  We know from many peoples’ experience over the years that you cannot “pray the gay away”.   Our religions tell us that we are born in the image of God, but we make the mistake of imposing our own images on the immutable “face of God”.

To those who want to make a positive difference, there is the Alana Faith Chen Foundation established by the family to reach out to those who suffer from mental health issues with special focus on the LGBTQ community.  To donate go to alanafaithchen.org.

 Let our meditation be to love others as ourselves and to pray that our traditional beliefs do not lead to the appalling outcome of the loss of a precious person who only wanted to love and be loved for who she was.

Is there a better city in the world to take two teenagers who have never been there? Uncle Ben was in charge of food, choosing the most authentic and varied restaurants to provide a tasting feast during our four days in New York City. Katz’s Deli may have been the most unique. At Becco’s Italian Restaurant with all you can eat pasta, we four toasted the achievements of Kris and Rae who successfully completed high school. Our private tour of the NYSE including being on the floor for the opening bell, was hugely impressive.  The 9/11 Memorial pools were a poignant reminder of the tragedy that changed the way we see the world.  Seeing Kinky Boots in a Broadway theater was another thrill.
During our “tourist time” on Times Square after the theater Ben and I watched the kids head for the Naked Cowboy who stood on the crowded sidewalk with his guitar wearing only his Jockey shorts. Then, even more eagerly, they rushed to have their pictures taken with a really naked young lady whose body was painted elaborately while her huge hot pink feather headdress bobbed invitingly.  We both agreed that even Paris wouldn’t be as great a place for two teens.

Kris who claims he doesn’t care for museums did agree to visit two. While Rae eagerly swept into the special Goth Fashion exhibit at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Ben and I guided Kris to see the Egyptian temple and he also admired the fully armored medieval knights and their weaponry. The Tenement Museum was new to all of us. Rae was emotionally immersed in the beautiful decay of that Lower East Side tenement building and the stories of the 19th century immigrants who lived there.

So they both had a landmark experience that they will always remember.  Ben was the perfect travel partner for me.  He could take them out at night when I was done for the day! What a wonderful Uncle, not to mention being a generous son as well. I was pleased with myself that I managed to keep up with them amazingly well despite lots of sweating in the 80+ degree heat and some sore feet. Staying at the Grand Hyatt next door to Grand Central Station was a perfect location.

“ Love is love” has won a victory on this day! June 26, 2015 will live in the annals of American history as a landmark day in human rights because marriage equality is now the law of our land.

It has been a 22-year journey for justice by our PFLAG Boulder County chapter which began with the agonizing disbelief of a handful of Boulder parents, allies, and LGBT people that Colorado citizens voted to make discrimination against gays and lesbians a constitutional amendment. We few were joined by many across Boulder County and eventually across our country that gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people and their families deserve full legal rights. We are proud and deeply moved by the social progress that has evolved in our lifetime. We are grateful to legislators and judges whose policies and decisions have affirmed our passion for change.

However, as we know all too painfully about racial equality, passing laws is only the beginning of erasing the prejudice that affects attitudes and behaviors. As we mourn the loss of lives of black Americans in Charleston on this same day, we reaffirm our commitment to bring “liberty and justice for all” a reality for all our citizens. PFLAG in its 375 chapters in all our fifty states will continue its work to change minds and hearts to make real the American Dream of equality for our transgender brothers and sisters, our racial and ethnic minorities, all who do not yet feel safe and welcome to be who they are.

Today I will hang my American flag from my balcony as a symbol of hope and of recommitment to continue the work for full equality and belonging for all Americans.

2013 marked forty years since Jeanne Manford, mother of a gay son, marched in a NYC Gay Pride Parade and carried a sign urging parents to support their gay and lesbian children. Thus did PFLAG begin in a United Methodist Church in Greenwich Village.  Ms. Manford, who died in January at the age of 93 was honored posthumously with a Citizen’s Award at the White House in February.  Jean Hodges was thrilled to be invited with National staff to attend the ceremony in the East Room where President Obama spoke eloquently about each recipient who received this highest civilian award for individual achievement.

My first impression of the West Bank, driving from Tel Aviv to Bethlehem was the walls.  Miles and miles of walls stood tall like sentinels along the highway, an ominous presence, separating the freedom of being Israeli from the Palestinian confinement by military occupation.  Reaching Bethlehem, I saw their quiet protest written in red paint on concrete walls that hugged the sidewalks as the driver and I wound our way to the Holy Land Hotel. 

More than the walls is the prejudice of the occupiers that we see reflected in our media. “Dirty Palestinians” is one epitaph; but the worst stereotype is “Palestinian terrorist.”   We heard many times from the mouths of priests, parents, and children: “We are not terrorists”.  And we believe it is true.

In a country plagued by unemployment, economic instability and isolation, where many young people have to leave the country to seek a college education; they seldom come back. As dismal as this reality is, the biggest surprise of the trip to Palestine is how much hope we found there. 

The Mar Elias School in the hilly town of Ibillin, close to the Prophet Elijah Mountain (translated “Mar Elias”), was only one source of hope we saw but an impressive one. Our visit began with the passionate talk by the school’s principal about the school’s ethos of mutual respect and living peacefully with religious differences.  No place for bullying here; leave that to the military presence at the check points.  Instead, following the International Baccalaureate curriculum, the school of four thousand focuses on academic achievement and is listed among the top ten schools in all of Israel. 

The middle and high school students we met were curious, grateful to see us and met us with huge grins of welcome. They asked some challenging questions:  “Is there discrimination against Arabs in the U.S.?  Tell us about racism.  We see U.S. TV and we wonder if every American carries a gun.  Is it true?  Tell us about Halloween.”

At the end of one class, a seventh grade girl held out her hand offering me her lady-bug earring.  She asked for something of mine in return.  We exchanged tokens and a friendship was born.  A sign of hope. 

My 85 year-old husband, Jack, was glowing with pleasure when I found him after a math class during a passing period.  Surrounded by a half dozen eager students, this retired math professor was writing some equations and prime numbers for this cluster of excited learners. Surely it was a highlight of his trip.  Hope is found in human exchange.

In Nazareth we learned more about hope rising from despair when we met Nabila Espanioly, a Palestinian Christian and life-long activist working for the well-being of children and the empowerment of women. I asked her what was the most challenging form of discrimination: being Arab in Israel, being women without power, or standing up to a conservative political system?  Her response: “There is no hierarchy of oppression. Where there is injustice there is a need to change systems, so we must act.”  I asked her about successes over the years and where she found hope.  Nabila replied, “I am not privileged enough to be pessimistic.  The oppressed must always hope or they couldn’t continue to strive for change.” 

A woman of courage who acts on her convictions, a priest who believed some 30 years ago that the path to dignity for Palestinians was through the education of the children, and the children, always the smiling, curious and eager children.  There lies an abundant hope for peace.

I heard Desmund Tutu (and maybe Martin L. King Jr. too) once say, “The arc of history bends toward justice.” Those words echoed in my mind when I was recently in the cast of “8”, listening to the words of the two lawyers from opposing political parties who teamed up to take on California’s ban on gay marriages, Proposition 8, to federal court. As I listened to the words from the court records during our one Boulder performance on December 6, I never dreamed that the Supreme Court would announce the very next day that they would hear arguments challenging both Proposition 8 and the federal Defense of Marriage Act. “It’s happening so fast,” I said to myself. Maybe I will live long enough to see my gay sons legally marry in Colorado!

What is the argument for the freedom to marry? As Theodore Olson, one of the lawyers stated federal court: “I believe, Your Honor, that there is a political tide turning. I think that people’s eyes are being opened. People are becoming more understanding and tolerant. The polls tell us that. That isn’t any secret”. He goes on to say that this case is going to be in a court where a judge is going to have to depend on more than public opinion; he will need to decide on a reason with real evidence that marriage equality does or does not do actual harm to society. He proclaims that ”it is not acceptable under our Constitution to deprive any citizens basic human rights that are guaranteed in our Constitution.” He says to the judge: “You cannot say, ‘We are going to take away the constitutional right to liberty , privacy, association, and sexual intimacy that we already tell you you have!’ So that case will now be heard by the Supreme Court sometime in April. And we wait breathlessly for the next historic moment. 

Lest we feel too confident…… we still have Utah…Missouri,…Montana… North Carolina. My weekend in Hamilton, Montana, at the PFLAG Pacific Northwest Regional Conference taught me so much about the disparities of progress toward LGBT equality. One lesbian member of the local chapter told me about her recent horrendous experience speaking to the Hamilton Board of Education. When she requested that sexual orientation be included in their non-discrimination policy, she was met by a barrage of bigoted comments from both Board members (four out of six are Tea Party members) and audience of ultra-conservatives. Instead of common agreement about bully-proofing that all students should be safe in school, she heard comments such as: “They don’t deserve protection—those gays are going to burn in Hell anyway. Let them take what they get!” Needless to say, she was devastated by the ugly prejudice but determined to return another day. 

I was in North Carolina this past spring just a week before the vote about including the ban on same-sex marriage in their Constitution. I read the Charlotte newspaper’s front page and saw that special feature highlighted the words of Franklin Graham, son of Billy Graham, who spoke of the “sanctity of marriage” and “disobeying God’s commands.” Other articles that were supportive of gay marriage were buried on back pages. One brave progressive Baptist minister wrote that the issue behind the vote was really about the separation of church and state, established by our Founders. Religious beliefs should not govern state policies. Didn’t our recent election cycle support that claim? 

At the same time in April, the United Methodist Church met in world-wide General Conference in Tampa to once again refuse to take out anti-gay policies from their Book of Discipline which governs church polity. I was moved to tears when the ministers in our own UMC in Boulder, Pat Bruns and Joe Agne, announced soon after the Tampa meetings that they were joining with other UM clergy across the country to defy church policy and agree to perform same-sex ceremonies in our church. 

So there is room for hope. This year we heard our first sitting President take a public stand on marriage equality. After thirty-two state over the past 20 years have banned same-sex marriage, this year in November, four states voted either to preserve the right to marriage equality in Maine or to vote against a ban in Maryland, Minnesota and Washington. Yes, the tide is turning. The arc of history is bending closer to justice; it is made up of historic moments that create eventual change.